Shores & Islands Ohio Antique and Unique Trail

Do you yearn to find treasure from years gone by? Are you always on the hunt for unique items to add to your vintage collections? Then antiquing is definitely for you! While Shores & Islands Ohio offers a number of unique shopping experiences, people often inquire as to which locations are good for browsing antiques and finding vintage items. Antique stores in the Shores & Islands Ohio region offer some really cool finds, especially for collectors of nautical items or items related to Lake Erie or the islands. 

Amherst 

Jamie’s Flea Market 

46388 Telegraph Rd. 

440-986-4402, 

Over 250 inside booths in two buildings. Vendors update inventory regularly. Up to 400 vendors set up outside. Browse sports memorabilia, other collectibles, vintage and gently used clothing, toys, vinyls. Find unique crafts, jewelry, or antiques, tools, and refurbished appliances for the home and garden. There are also plenty of food options. Year-round, Wed and Sat 8 am-4 pm 

Kelleys Island 

Island wide 

419-746-2360,

Treasure Island Day is an annual September island tradition where local businesses on Kelleys Island hold sidewalk/yard sales and island residents host yard and garage sales. Grab a ferry to Kelleys Island for this fun antiquing find and check it out the weekend after Labor Day! 

The Island Flea at The Village Peddler 

130 Division St. 

419-746-2377,

The Island Flea offers a fresh alternative to island shopping with an ever-changing line of items. A treasure trove of unique finds, antiques and local artisan goods that will make you smile and offer unique items for your home or cottage. Mar-Dec, daily 10 am-5 pm. 

Parsonage Resale Shop at Kelleys Island Historical Association 

224 Division St. 

419-746-2399, 

Every room in the house is bursting with unique items such as household appliances, elegant tableware, vintage pieces, children’s toys, books, and more. The proceeds from The Parsonage Resale Shop contribute to the restoration projects of the Kelleys Island Historical Association and the repair and upkeep of the house. Open Memorial Day-Labor Day, daily; other times by appointment.  

Huron 

City Wide Garage Sale  

Huron Boat Basin, 330 Main St., 

Rain or shine. May 17, 2025, 9 am-1 pm  

Milan 

Mid Summer Antique Festival 

Milan Town Square 

419-499-4909 

This event celebrates the rich history and charm of antiques, providing a unique opportunity for collectors, enthusiasts, and vendors to come together in our vibrant community. July 13, 2025, 8 am-4 pm. 

Crosby’s Antiques 

4 N. Main St. 

419-499-4001, 

Crosby's Antiques buys and sells fine, quality antique furniture, pottery, jewelry, dolls, glassware, and more. Proprietor conducts estate sales, and appraisals are available. Tues-Sat 11 am-4 pm, or by chance. 

Roll It Forward Rummage Sale 

11001 US 250 N, Building B, Unit 5 

419-602-9931,

A community-focused store that offers a wide variety of gently-used items for sale at affordable prices. Each rummage sale allows various area non-profits an opportunity to raise funding through the sales of donated items. Feb-Nov, Fri-Sat 9 am-3 pm. 

Milan Inn-tiques 

29 E. Church St. 

419-706-3252, 

Located on the historic village square, originally an 1845 stagecoach inn, Milan Inn-tiques offers antiques and collectibles. Enjoy daily/weekly stays/events on the 2nd floor, fully equipped and furnished vacation rental space. Relax on a new 14'x16' deck. Open year-round. Visit Coffee Station on the main floor. 

Port Clinton 

Liberty Aviation Museum Gift Shop 

3515 E. State. Rd. 

419-732-0234,

Offering one-of-a-kind items and artwork including models, books, souvenirs, toys, and nostalgic memorabilia of museum-related aircraft and aviation themed items. Mar 20-May 1, Thurs-Fri 10 am-4 pm, Sat-Sun 10 am-5 pm; May-Dec, Mon-Fri 10 am-4 pm, Sat-Sun 9 am-5 pm. 

Lighthouse Center Resale Shop 

974 Gypsum Rd. 

419-732-2399 

A nonprofit offering quality used merchandise in a clean and organized setting serviced by friendly and dedicated volunteers. All merchandise is donated from around the community and proceeds buy food to be distributed through the community free of charge. Year-round, Mon-Wed and Fri 9:30 am-3 pm, Sat 9 am-1 pm. 

Portage Resale Center 

301 W. 2nd St. 

419-732-1780,

Come in and shop the 10,000 sq. ft. facility for gently used clothing, furniture, houseware, small appliances, toys, children’s items, books, and more. Year-round, Mon, Wed, Fri, Sat 9:30 am-3 pm. 

Put-in-Bay 

Island Wide Garage Sale 

The Island Wide Garage Sale is an annual May tradition! Residents and businesses across the islands open their garages and lawns to bargain hunters and vintage enthusiasts alike, offering a unique shopping experience. Discover hidden gems, rare antiques, and eclectic items as you explore sales peppered throughout the charming island. May 17, 2025, 10 am-6 pm 

Lake Erie Island Historical Society Resale Shop 

25 Town Hall Place, Put-in-Bay 

419.285.0097, 

The Lake Erie Islands Historical Society's Heritage Resale Shop is staffed by volunteers and all items inside are generously donated. All proceeds go to support the Historical Society and Museum. 

Sandusky 

Grace Thrift Store 

301 E. Market St. 

419-626-5453, 

A volunteer-run consignment shop in downtown Sandusky with all proceeds going towards community outreach. Donations accepted. Serving the community since 1948. Year-round, Tues-Sat. 

The Encore Shop 

2215 Cleveland Rd. W. 

419-502-0019, 

Encore is an upscale resale shop with proceeds from the shop benefitting the patients of Stein Hospice. Shop clothing, jewelry, housewares, home décor, furniture, books, and much more! Unique items for everyone. Shop and make a difference. Year-round, Tues-Sat 10 am-4 pm; accessible. 

Lake Erie Gifts & Décor 

1521 Cleveland Rd. W. 

419-627-0015, 

One of Northern Ohio’s largest primitive home décor and country gift shops and antique mall. Offering decorative style favorites including nautical and beach décor. Find everything from primitive furniture, souvenirs, specialty jams, salsas, soup mixes, candles, and tabletop décor. Check out "The Back Room: Antiques, Collectibles, and Curiosities." Year-round, Mon-Sat 10 am-6 pm. 

Nautical Flea Market 

at Maritime Museum of Sandusky, 125 Meigs St. 

419-624-0274, 

Discover prints, charts, books, boats, engines, spare parts, and a wide array of nautical decor! May 3, 2025, 9 am-4 pm